Nope, according to Seaspiracy, it’s the globally powerful and corrupt fishing industry, which is getting billions in subsidies from governments around the world – adding up to $35,000,000,000 billion to be precise. Oh and side-note, there’ll be no fish left in the ocean by 2048.
Of course, we won’t die when the sea is empty, that will happen long before, when critical ocean ecosystems have collapsed (which is already predicted), and that will trigger off massive challenges in how the ocean contributes to a live-able environment for all life on earth.
So if we put it in order, first to suffer (and they already are) will be communities relying on the ocean for their livelihood and sustenance, and then once they’re decimated, it will be our turn. A dead ocean is not a good thing for life on land.
The reality is, this crisis has been emerging for a long time and we aren’t anywhere near addressing it with the urgency it deserves. For me, Seaspiracy is just an addition to a bigger story we need to understand. I mean, check out this piece: Scientists: Mass Extinction Is Coming as Organisms Flee the Equator.
But was Seaspiracy good enough?
When I started watching Seaspiracy, I have to be honest and say I was a little underwhelmed. Ali Tabrizi was so naïve about the state of our oceans at the beginning of his research, which left me thinking – how could you not know?
The information is out there for the world to see, but then, in my experience, it reminded me that this is not an uncommon place for anyone to be… at the start, before you really start to know the enormous scale of what is going on. Before you confront the truth of what humans are doing to our planet.
As it went on, Tabrizi’s naivety became a powerful thread throughout the documentary in the end. Watching someone wake up is very powerful, because when you know, man you see what a perilous line we are walking as a species. Regardless of whether you agree with Seaspiracy or not, he’s shined a light on the vast impact humans are having on the ocean, a light that is so needed!
Since the documentary was released, I’ve waited to write or talk about it. I watched it when it was released and again a week later with my family. But I’ve also been watching the commentary about it, from friends, the media and professionals in the field, and it’s an interesting conversation. Some say it’s too sensationalist, and the research isn’t there to back it up – remember The Game Changers? It’s still being debunked.
So has it been debunked? Take a look at these reviews and articles
Seaspiracy fact check: What Netflix documentary is about, and why its accuracy has faced questions
Seaspiracy: Netflix documentary accused of misrepresentation by participants
Stream It Or Skip It: ‘Seaspiracy’ on Netflix, a Revealing Documentary Targeting the Corruption of the Commercial Fishing Industry – good for those who found it sensationalist
Seaspiracy review – a damning documentary dredges up the dirt
Seaspiracy: The 7 biggest claims from the new documentary
Sustainably Yours: 15 reasons to stop eating seafood
EU humiliated after bloc banned single-use plastic: ‘Fishing nets far more dangerous’
EU ‘plundering African continent’ as Seaspiracy probe exposes horrific fishing practices
Seaspiracy: The New Netflix Documentary That Will Stop You Eating Fish
‘It’s like a horror movie’: Heart-wrenching scenes of whale hunt in Netflix documentary Seaspiracy has viewers in tears
Seaspiracy shows why we must treat fish not as seafood, but as wildlife
Is Netflix’s Seaspiracy film right about fishing damaging oceans?
Not conclusive! The primary criticism is misrepresentation and questionable or out-of-date facts. So as I like to do (to make it easy for you to dig in), at the bottom of this blog, you’ll see lots of links to articles and research that discusses the state of the oceans and the creatures living in it.
Because no matter which way we look at it, we are destroying the foundations of our ability to live and what is happening in the ocean is a HUGE part of that problem. If we continue to ignore this, our children will not have a live-able future.
We won’t either. If you’re mid-60s and below, you WILL be alive to experience the devastating impact. It’s cumulative too and will only get worse if we do not stop. PLEASE do your research and know the truth for yourself. My reading list below is a good starting point.
Here’s a flavor of the key information in Seaspiracy
- There is no such thing as dolphin safe, so don’t buy tins of tuna
- There is no such thing as sustainable fishing either
- The best thing we can do is boycott seafood and force our governments to get overfishing under control, with a focus on getting life in the oceans back to a level necessary to sustain life, and by default, all life on land
- Dolphins and whales are critical for the planet’s health – if they die, the ocean dies. Remarkably, 300,000 whales and dolphins are killed as bycatch every year
- I have been tracking the barbarity in Taiji thanks to my friend Vicki Kiely making me aware of it. What I hadn’t heard before is the dolphins are being killed because they are considered pests! This is apparently to cover up the fact that the multi-billion Bluefin Tuna Industry is overfishing this incredibly valuable fish. Since 1970, less than 3% of Bluefin remain, and well, it’s a $42 billion industry being protected there. We can’t eat money Mitsubishi
- Another industry we have heard a lot about over the last couple of decades is the Shark fin industry, also a billion dollar industry! Across all species, 80-99% of sharks are gone, and yet, as they sit at the top of an ecosystem, they are critical for ocean life! Not to mention, we kill 11,000-30,000 sharks/hour, and 50 million sharks are killed as bycatch. I say we, because we are all liable when we support any industry
- There is 150 million tons of plastic in the ocean, which equals a truck load dumped into the ocean every minute. While it’s great we are tackling single use plastics, like straws (which only accounts for 0.03% of ocean plastic according to Seaspiracy), it doesn’t mean we shouldn’t prioritize getting rid of consumer plastic. However, we must address the fact that 46% of ocean plastic is fishing nets, which is enough fishing line to wrap around the world 500x every day. It’s an industry in disarray, doing so much damage to the planet and it needs to be addressed
- Some other stats include Halibut is 1,000 times less abundant than in the 1800s, 90% of coral reefs will be gone by 2050 (this devastates me) and 30% of mangrove has been lost for shrimp and fish farming. Mangroves protect human life, so this is a double whammy
The subject of slavery
There are more slaves now than at any time in history and with Covid, it’s expected to get worse. Human slavery in the fishing industry is a well-known fact, and while Ali seemed surprised by it, I’m glad it was highlighted, because it’s a terrible and brutal reality for too many. Are we happy eating food that causes suffering? Then again, this is an issue I care about well beyond the fishing industry – our ability to turn a blind eye to the barbarity and environmental destruction in the supply chain. Time to face it and our role in it.
The subject of Asia
Without Japan, China and other large populations in Asia on board for the fight for ocean health, we cannot win. We need these nations to understand and do their part, or we can’t succeed. We can ramp up the pressure, but the change must come from within these countries.
My birthday is a bleak day
I was born on the 1st of January 1970. This is the year most extinction events and population declines are measured from. Since that day, we have seen a 68% Average Decline in Species Population Sizes on land, and in Central and South America, that number is even larger – a 94 percent fall in species since 1970, with 75 percent of fish stock over-exploited, according to this article.
Equally, many freshwater fish species have declined by 76 percent in less than 50 years. Just five years ago, it was 50 percent. A frightening escalation and we don’t seem to want to do anything about it.
We can see the numbers? They are increasing rapidly. It’s more than a 20 percent jump in just a few years. When will we stop? For many species, it’s already too late.
So it’s time to ask ourselves – isn’t this worth fighting for? Isn’t this really the only thing that matters right now?
And if you have children, listen to their dreams, look into their eyes when they share them, look at their passion? Then ask yourself – is this even going to be possible for them? If we keep going the way we’re going, I don’t think it is and it’s breaking my heart.
Digging deeper into the state of our oceans
If you really want to get an up-to-date view on the state of our oceans, please spend some time with this information. It is not everything, but I’ve been pulling it together since Seaspiracy was launched and want to encourage everyone who was passionate about that documentary to dig in more.
Please, don’t ever rely on one source or one opinion. Read widely and make your mind up. Then decide what you can do to make a difference. When we know, we can act, but we’ve got to know the truth of the situation.
When you are informed (and it can be awful to face it, so go easy on yourself as you’re likely to experience intense emotions) then speak up. Speak to your government. Speak to your community. Speak to your local fishing industry. Share your knowledge with people who can make a difference.
If you don’t think activism works, times are changing. Read this piece Why Companies Should Engage with Activists. Your voice matters. All of our voices matter.
Here’s some links to get you started on your knowledge journey
I’ve spent 8 years campaigning for the oceans: here’s what I wish more people understood
How Industrial Fishing Creates More CO2 Emissions Than Air Travel
Antarctic ‘doomsday glacier’ may be melting faster than was thought
Do you know where plastic waste in the oceans is coming from?
Scientists: Mass Extinction Is Coming as Organisms Flee the Equator
How climate change relates to oceans
How data is transforming the way we care for the ocean
Bottom Trawling Releases As Much Carbon Emissions As Global Aviation
How Will Commercial Fishing Pressure Affect Skipjack Tuna?
A shark’s eye view on ocean ecology
Thousands of barrels of suspected toxic DDT found dumped in California ocean
Functional consequences of global biodiversity loss guide future nature conservation
‘Outdated’ Netflix documentary sparks ire
Satellite Imagery Shows Northern California Kelp Forests Have Collapsed
Limited monitoring and government oversight depleting shark populations
Pollution from fishing vessels
Ice age: Franz Josef Glacier loses 1km within 10 years
How the Seafood Industry is Polluting the Ocean and Killing Off Marine Life
Species that Suffer from Illegal Activities on the Ocean
Why are glaciers and sea ice melting?
Baby fish have started eating plastic. We haven’t yet seen the consequences
Orcas: Facts about killer whales
Plastic pollution disproportionately hitting marginalised groups, UN environment report finds
The Speed of Ocean Currents Is Changing in a Major Way, Scientists Warn
Is the Southern Ocean absorbing or emitting carbon dioxide?
Extinction: ‘Time is running out’ to save sharks and rays
‘Nothing about the Mekong is normal now’: Anger along Southeast Asia’s great river as water levels become unpredictable
Are Dolphins Endangered? They Are and the Sad Reasons Matter
Top 10 Most Endangered Animals
How Will Commercial Fishing Pressure Affect Skipjack Tuna?
Salmon, Orcas, Rivers, and Sound: Our Interconnected Biodiversity in the Pacific Northwest
Up to one million tonnes of ‘deadly’ fishing gear left in ocean each year, WWF warns
Was Seaspiracy a perfect overview of the situation? No, it wasn’t. But was it wrong to do an alarming documentary on the state of our oceans? Definitely not. Now it’s our turn to do the work so we know what’s going on. The information is out there, we’ve just got to spend time with it. Once we know we all act and change this path. We can do it if enough of us get involved. Rise my friends, rise!
Thanks for reading and I hope you find the additional links valuable. Please do drop me a note and tell me what you think? Did you love Seaspiracy? Find it sensationalist? Left you wondering what the truth really is?
Coming soon – Uncommon Courage
18 Steps to an All-Star LinkedIn Profile
18 Steps to an All-Star LinkedIn Profile is listed by Book Authority in the 100 Best LinkedIn Books of All Time and 22 Best New LinkedIn eBooks To Read In 2021 categories. Grab it today if you want to take your professional presence to the next level!
When it comes to LinkedIn, it really is time to ask — can you really afford not to have this book in the hands of every employee?
Connect with me
Website, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, Instagram, Medium, SlideShare, Amazon.
Join my new Facebook GroupUncommon Courage.
Check out my regularly updated Environment Referencesblog.
Have I done a great job for you? Can you write a reference on my LinkedIn profile or on my Google Business page? If not for me, why not write one for someone else who inspires you or has helped you? Join the #GivingEconomy
Check out Second Nature Social
This is a new series, designed to help beginners get up to speed with everything necessary on social media. Follow my YouTube channel and see the latest.
Are you a Social CEO?
I’m proud to be a contributing author to The Social CEO: How Social Media Can Make You A Stronger Leader. You can order it on Amazon today.
Want to claim your stage?
Check out our co-authored Best Selling Book – Unleash Your Voice – Powerful Public Speaking for Every Woman – proud to be part of this too!
Want proof social leadership transforms business and attracts customers?
Check out this case study with IBM Asia Pacific. Incredible results.
Want to be a super star online?
Don’t know where to start, check out my e-learning course How to build a rock star personal brand today.
I believe it’s time for all of us to embrace our voice and embrace the future. We do this by working and living ‘out loud’ with meaning, intention, integrity and by being true to ourselves. If you own your voice, you own your future.